Does Mindfulness Really Help with Mental Health Conditions? What 142 Studies Show
A large meta-analysis tested mindfulness programs in people with psychiatric diagnoses and compared them with control groups of different strength. The result is encouraging, and also sobering.
When I tell people I teach mindfulness, one of the first questions I hear is whether it actually works or whether it's just another trend. It's a fair question. There are many small studies, and it's easy to pick only the ones that fit the story. That's why I value good meta-analyses, which pool all the studies and ask what the overall picture looks like.
In early 2018, Simon Goldberg and colleagues from the University of Wisconsin and the VA Puget Sound Health Care System in Seattle published one in Clinical Psychology Review. They gathered 142 separate study samples with 12,005 participants, all people with a clinical diagnosis such as depression, anxiety, addiction or chronic pain. The smart move was to grade the comparison groups by strength, from people who got no treatment at all up to people who received a treatment already shown to work.
At the end of treatment, mindfulness beat no treatment with an effect size of 0.55, which counts as moderate. Against other active treatments the gap shrank to between 0.23 and 0.35. Against evidence-based treatments there was no difference. The most consistent evidence was for depression, pain, smoking and addictive disorders.
These numbers need careful reading. The stronger the comparison group, the smaller the advantage. So part of the improvement comes from general factors like a supportive group, an attentive teacher and the expectation of getting better. And finding no difference from a proven treatment doesn't mean mindfulness can replace it. The authors phrased their conclusion carefully: mindfulness-based interventions hold promise as evidence-based treatments.
Why it matters for our lives
For me, this study is a lesson in humility. Mindfulness is a tool with a real, measurable effect, in the same range as other treatments we trust, and it is not a miracle cure. If you're dealing with depression or anxiety, think of practice as one part of a broader plan. Tell the professional who supports you about it, and don't drop a treatment that is helping you because of it.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2017.10.011