Meditation has side effects too. Let's talk about it
A Brown University study systematically tracked difficult experiences among people taking an eight-week mindfulness course. Most were passing, but not all.
Anyone who has sat a long retreat knows meditation isn't always pleasant. Sometimes fear, sadness or memories show up uninvited. I try to talk about this openly in my courses, and a study published in 2021 gave me numbers to work with.
Willoughby Britton and her team at Brown University followed 96 people who took MBCT, an eight-week group mindfulness program. Afterwards an independent interviewer went through 44 possible experiences with each participant, asking whether it happened, whether it was linked to practice, how long it lasted, whether it felt good or bad, and whether it affected their functioning.
83% reported at least one meditation-related effect. Some of these were neutral or even pleasant. 58% had at least one that felt negative, and 37% reported some negative impact on functioning, usually temporary.
For 6% to 14% of participants there were lasting bad effects. These tended to go with signs of dysregulated arousal: feeling keyed up and unable to settle, or feeling detached from one's body and surroundings.
The authors note that rates of transient distress were similar to what we see in other psychological treatments. In other words, meditation behaves like a real intervention. It has power, so it can also carry a cost.
Keep the limits in mind. This is a fairly small sample of people who came in with mild to severe depressive symptoms and persistent negative mood, so rates may differ in other groups. Still, it is one of the first studies to measure this carefully, and it changed how I teach.
Why it matters for our lives
The point is to practice wisely, not to fear practice. If during a sit your heart starts racing or you feel yourself drifting away, you can open your eyes, stand up, move, feel your feet on the floor. You can also make the session shorter. And if something difficult lingers afterwards, tell your teacher or a professional. A good teacher will want to know.
https://doi.org/10.1177/2167702621996340