Mindfulness in schools: what we learned from a trial that didn't work
The UK's MYRIAD trial included more than 8,000 students. The mindfulness program did no better than usual lessons, and there is a lot to learn from that.
In July 2022 the results came out from one of the largest trials ever run on mindfulness in schools. It's called MYRIAD, and its main result wasn't what many of us hoped for. I think that's exactly why it's worth reading.
A team led by Willem Kuyken at Oxford randomly assigned 85 UK schools to two groups. In half, students aged 11 to 14 got ten mindfulness lessons taught by trained school teachers. The other half carried on with their usual social and emotional learning. The analysis included 8,376 students.
After a year there was no difference. Not in risk for depression, not in social-emotional-behavioral functioning, not in well-being. The differences between groups were very close to zero. On the other hand, no program-related adverse events were seen, and the economic analysis suggested it was likely cost-effective.
It matters what the program was compared with. Control schools were already teaching social and emotional skills. The trial wasn't asking whether mindfulness beats nothing. It asked whether mindfulness adds to what schools already do, and the answer was no.
What does that mean? My reading is that it's very hard to bring an inner practice to a whole class of teenagers who didn't choose it, through regular school teachers, in ten lessons. The authors themselves say we need to ask what works, for whom and how.
I have a lot of respect for a team that publishes a result like this openly. That's what makes science something we can trust.
Why it matters for our lives
Parents and educators often ask me whether to bring mindfulness into the classroom. After MYRIAD, my answer is to be careful with big expectations from a short program for everyone. Think about fit: who wants it, who needs it, and who is teaching. At home, sometimes the biggest effect comes from an adult who practices and shows what it looks like to pause and breathe when angry.
https://doi.org/10.1136/ebmental-2021-300396