עב WhatsApp
Back to all articles
October 14, 2024·Pain·3 min read

Mindfulness vs. Placebo: The Brain Eases Pain in Two Different Ways

Is pain relief from meditation just expectation? A Biological Psychiatry study found that mindfulness and placebo act on different brain patterns.

One question has followed mindfulness and pain research for years: maybe all the relief is a placebo effect? People expect meditation to help, so they feel less pain. It is a fair question, and I am glad some labs take it seriously.

In August 2024, Fadel Zeidan's group at UC San Diego, together with Tor Wager of Dartmouth, published a paper in Biological Psychiatry. They combined data from two randomized trials with 115 healthy participants, split into four groups: four sessions of mindfulness meditation (37 people), a placebo cream with conditioning (19), a sham version of meditation (20), and listening to a book (39). Everyone then received 49°C heat on the skin during functional MRI.

Instead of looking at a single brain region, the researchers used brain 'signatures', multi-region activity patterns validated in earlier work. One signature tracks the processing of the painful input itself, another tracks the negative emotional side of pain, and a third tracks the placebo response.

The result was what scientists call a double dissociation. Meditation reduced pain intensity and unpleasantness more than every other group, and it also lowered the signatures for pain processing and negative affect. The placebo cream, in contrast, lowered the placebo signature. Both approaches reduce pain, through different routes in the brain.

There are limits here. The participants were healthy, the pain was brief and experimental, and chronic pain was not tested. Some groups were small, especially the placebo and sham groups. The data also came from two separate trials that used different scanning methods.

Why it matters for our lives

When I teach people who live with pain, I don't promise the pain will disappear. This study gives me grounds to say that what happens in meditation goes beyond expectation. You can try it the next time something hurts. Instead of fighting the sensation, get curious about it. Where exactly is it? Is it steady or does it shift? For some people, this kind of looking changes their relationship to pain even when its intensity barely moves.

SourceRiegner, G., Dean, J., Wager, T. D., & Zeidan, F. (2025). Mindfulness meditation and placebo modulate distinct multivariate neural signatures to reduce pain. Biological Psychiatry, 97(1), 81–88. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsych.2024.08.023 (Published online August 30, 2024)
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsych.2024.08.023

More articles