Mindfulness and Sleep: What 18 Controlled Trials Say
A meta-analysis by researchers at the US National Institutes of Health asked whether mindfulness meditation improves sleep quality, and compared to what.
In every course I teach, someone tells me they fell asleep during the body scan. It always gets a laugh, and it also raises a serious question: does mindfulness actually improve sleep? Sleep and stress are tightly linked. Bad nights push stress up, and stress makes it harder to fall asleep.
Rusch and colleagues at the US National Institutes of Health published a meta-analysis on this in the Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. Out of 3,303 records they screened, 18 randomized trials with 1,654 participants made it into the analysis. They compared mindfulness only against active control groups, never against waitlists, to rule out the effect of simply getting some treatment and attention.
Against general active controls matched for time, mindfulness improved sleep quality. The effect size was 0.33 at the end of the intervention and 0.54 at follow-up, and the researchers rated the strength of evidence as moderate. Against dedicated sleep treatments with proven efficacy, there was no difference.
Keep in mind that the researchers rated the evidence for the comparison with sleep treatments as low, so we can't yet say mindfulness is equivalent to them. The authors themselves call the findings preliminary. What I find interesting is that the effect at follow-up was larger than right at the end, as if the benefit keeps growing over time.
Why it matters for our lives
If you've had insomnia for a long time, it's worth seeking dedicated treatment first, such as cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia. Mindfulness can come alongside it, or help people whose sleep simply gets shaky during stressful periods. A small suggestion: when you're lying awake, instead of fighting your thoughts, move your attention to the sensation of breathing in your belly. The aim isn't to fall asleep, just to be there.
https://doi.org/10.1111/nyas.13996