What does mindfulness do for people without a diagnosis? A review of 136 trials
A large review published in January 2021 pooled 136 randomized trials with more than 11,000 participants. The picture is encouraging, and it also reminds us not to overstate things.
When people ask me whether mindfulness works, I usually answer with a question: works for what, and compared with what? In January 2021 PLOS Medicine published a review that tackles exactly that, and I keep coming back to it.
A team led by Julieta Galante at the University of Cambridge gathered every randomized controlled trial of in-person mindfulness programs for adults in nonclinical settings. Think employees and students, people without a diagnosis. In total: 136 trials and 11,605 participants from 29 countries.
Compared with doing nothing, the programs reduced anxiety, depression and psychological distress on average, and improved mental well-being. The effects were roughly moderate. For anxiety the average standardized effect was 0.56, and for distress 0.45.
The more interesting part is the comparison with other programs. When mindfulness was compared with other interventions designed to promote mental health, there was no significant evidence that it did better. Against more general activities that weren't built for that purpose, it came out ahead only on depression.
The authors are upfront that confidence in the findings ranges from moderate to very low. Many trials had a high risk of bias, and when those were removed only the effect on distress held up. Programs aimed at people at higher risk showed larger effects than programs offered to everyone.
I find this a healthy review. It says mindfulness helps ordinary people, it says mindfulness is one good tool among several, and it says we still need to learn where it fits best.
Why it matters for our lives
If you're torn between mindfulness and some other way of looking after your mind, this review takes some pressure off. There's no magic bullet here, just several approaches that work about equally well. So pick the one you'll actually stick with. A small suggestion: try ten minutes a day for eight weeks, then ask yourself honestly what changed.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003481